The Mystillery blog
Friday, October 10, 2025
Saturday, October 4, 2025
The Case of the Restless Redhead by Erle Stanley Gardner (1954)
Thursday, September 25, 2025
The Excursion Train by Edward Marston (2005)
Series: Railway Detective #2
About the author: Edward Marston is a pseudonym of Keith Miles.
Major characters:
- Inspector Robert Colbeck, Scotland Yard
- Sam Horlock, railway policeman
- Tod Galway, train guard (conductor)
Caleb Andrews (train driver)
Madeleine Andrews, his daughter - Bill Hignett, "The Bargeman", a prizefighter
- Isaac Rosen, "Mad Isaac", a prizefighter
- Jacob Guttridge/Bransby; public executioner (victim)
- Louise Guttridge/Bransby, his widow
- Michael Guttridge/Eames; their son
- Becky Guttridge/Eames; Michael's wife
- William Calcraft, public executioner
- Superintendent Edward Tallis
- Inspector Robert Colbeck
- Sergeant Victor Leeming
Locale: London and environs
Synopsis: An excursion train runs from London to the countryside to bring a rowdy crowd to a prizefight between "The Bargeman" (Bill Hignett) and "Mad Isaac" (Isaac Rosen) . After the fans leave the train at the destination, a body is found by railway policeman Sam Horlock in one of the coaches - murdered. Scotland Yard inspector Robert Colbeck, "The Railway Detective", is sent into the investigation. The murdered man is Jacob Guttridge, a public executioner (hangman); who lived incognito with his wife Louise under her maiden name (Bransby). Plenty of people had a motive of retribution, as he had been responsible for hanging quite a few.
Colbeck looks up his friend, train driver Caleb Andrews, for insight into the railway workings; as well as getting closer to his romantic interest, Caleb's daughter Madeleine.
Saturday, September 20, 2025
All for the Love of a Lady by Leslie Ford, 1943
Series: Colonel Primrose #11
About the author: Leslie Ford is a pseudonym of Zenith Jones Brown, 1898-1984. She also wrote as David Frome and Brenda Conrad. Also see this Book Scribbles blog: Leslie Ford's Fall From Grace.
Locale: Washington DC
Major characters:
- Grace Latham, our narrator
- Colonel John Primrose
- Sgt. Phineas T. Buck
- Molly Crane, nurse's aide
- Cass Crane, her husband
- Randy Fleming, Molly's former boyfriend
- D.J. Durbin, mysterious war industry financier
- Achille, his chauffeur
- Courtney Durban, his wife
- Duleep Singh, economist
- Horace Blodgett, corporate lawyer
- Corinne Blodgett, his wife
- Mr. Austin, a.k.a. Mr. Armistead
- Lons Sondauer, a.k.a. Louis Skagerlund
Synopsis: In the midst of wartime Washington DC, the story follows two couples: Cass and Molly Crane - Cass being expected home on leave any moment, and Molly a nurse's aide. D.J. Durbin, wealthy industrialist and his wife Courtney. The couples are connected as Cass and Courtney had intended to marry before she met Durbin. On the side is Randy Fleming, Molly's former boyfriend. Problems begin when Cass notifies Courtney (not his wife) that he will be home any moment. Then Durbin's chauffeur, Achille, dies after drinking poisoned alcohol in the Crane's home - but for whom was it intended?
Please note there are troubling references to animal abuse/killing (cats and kittens) as well as two instances of the N-word, as used in the old colloquial expression about a woodpile. Cat lovers may wish to take a pass on this one.
You may also enjoy this review by Bev Hankins on My Reader's Block.
Friday, September 12, 2025
Three at Wolfe's Door by Rex Stout, 1960
Mini-review: It is difficult to follow which woman served which member unless it is charted out, and I didn't bother. They narrow the field down quickly, then use a clever ruse to make the killer reveal herself. The coaching and use of Zoltan, a kitchen worker, is quite enjoyable.
Mini-review: There's a few too many characters for this short novella, and the timeline analysis is a bit overdone, but the major characters are well done. The tough-talking woman cabbie is a delight.
Mini-review: The cowboy drawl and vocabulary got tiring pretty quickly. That plus the ridiculous setup of a lasso contest in Manhattan made the whole thing quite unreal; and the sorting out of alibis tedious. Worst of the three stories.
Wednesday, September 3, 2025
The White Elephant Mystery by Ellery Queen, Jr., 1950
- Djuna
- Tommy Williams, his friend
- Miss Annie Ellery, Djuna's guardian(?)
- Mr. George Boots, carpenter
- "Socker" Furlong, reporter
- "Cannonball" McGinnty, state trooper
- Alvah Grant, founder of the circus (dead prior to story)
- Sonny Grant, Alvah's son, new owner of the circus
- Norman "Spitfire" Peters, aerialist
- Trixie Cella, Spitfire's wife, aerialist
- Ned Barrow, Spitfire's catcher
• The Golden Eagle Mystery (1942)
• The Green Turtle Mystery (1944)
• The Red Chipmunk Mystery (1946)
• The Brown Fox Mystery (1948)
• The White Elephant Mystery (1950)
• The Yellow Cat Mystery (1952)
• The Blue Herring Mystery (1954)
• The Purple Bird Mystery (1966)
• The Mystery of the Merry Magician (1954)
• The Mystery of the Vanished Victim (1954)
Wednesday, August 27, 2025
The Mystery of the Gold Box by Valentine Williams, 1932
- Philip Clavering, alias James Dunlop, British Secret Service, and our narrator
- Garnet Wolseley, operative for British Secret Service
- Charles Forrest, British Secret Service (dead at opening of story)
- Dr. Adolph Grundt, German spy
- Madeleine Stafford, German agent
- Amschel Lipschutz, German agent H. 79, (dead at opening of story)