Monday, February 18, 2019

In The Onyx Lobby by Carolyn Wells (1920)

Kobo Rakuten

Feb 18 2019: Please check back. Currently reading, I fill this post in as I go along. RM

About the author: Carolyn Wells (1862-1942) was married to Hadwin Houghton, the heir of the Houghton-Mifflin publishing empire. Like Mary Roberts Rinehart, being in a publishing family created an easy pipeline for getting her works into print. She wrote a total of more than 170 books, including 61 Fleming Stone detective stories. See this Wikipedia article.

Carolyn Wells

Major characters:

Sir Herbert Binney, baker of 'Binney's Buns'
Miss Letitia Prall, "The Grenadier",
Richard "Rick" Bates, Letitia's nephew
Eliza Gurney, Letitia's companion
Adeline Everett
Dorcas Everett, Adeline's daughter, engaged to Richard Bates

Locale: New York City

Synopsis: Sir Herbert Binney, successful baker in England, has come to the US to expand his business. He wants to enlist his distant relative Richard Bates, by offering to make him heir to his empire if he accepts.

Bates lives with his aunt, Miss Letitia Prall, who has a long-running undefined feud with Adeline Everett, who lives in another apartment in the luxurious Campanile. Adeline's daughter, Dorcas Everett, is secretly engaged to Bates.

Eliza Gurney, companion to Letitia, catches on and spills it to Letitia, which escalates the feud.

While Bates is considering whether to 1) accept Binney's offer and 2) continue his engagement, Binney is found dead in the Onyx Lobby.

Review: I was only a few pages in when I realized I have heard this all before. Two single parents, neighbors, having a long-running but unexplained feud - and their children secretly in love? This is the same plot as the off-Broadway The Fantasticks.

Tuesday, February 12, 2019

Speak No Evil by Mignon Eberhart (1940)

About the author: (from Goodreads): Mignon Good (1899-1996) was born in Lincoln, Nebraska. In 1929 her first crime novel was published featuring 'Sarah Keate', a nurse and 'Lance O'Leary', a police detective. This couple appeared in another four novels. Over the next forty years she wrote a novel nearly every year. In 1971 she won the Grand Master award from the Mystery Writers of America. 

Major characters:

Elizabeth Coolman Dakin
Major Robert Dakin, her alcoholic husband
Dyke Sanderson, her boyfriend, and Robert's nephew
Ruth Reddington, Dakin's business associate
Charlie Hawes, Dakin's secretary
Leech, their butler
Marianna, their maid
Charmian Dakin, Dakin's first wife
Cyril Kirby, an English yachtsman
Inspector Paul Friker, of the police

Locale: Jamaica

Synopsis: In their Jamaican villa, Elizabeth Dakin is already regretting her empty marriage to unstable Robert Dakin, a successful businessman in war materiel. He is also a dipsomaniac (obsolete word for alcoholic). She is hoping to reunite with her old flame, Dyke Sanderson (also Dakin's nephew). 

Dyke arrives, along with Dakin's business partner, cool, elegant Ruth Reddington; who attaches herself to Dakin while Elizabeth tries to reunite with Dyke. 

Dakin gives Elizabeth some precious emerald jewelry, and has her wear it to a dinner along with Dakin's friend, Cyril Kirby; who also has his eye out for Elizabeth. At the dinner, she encounters Dakin's catty first wife, Charmian, who says the jewels rightfully belong to her. Awkward.

Back home after the dinner, Elizabeth tells Dakin she plans to leave him. Then Dakin is found in his study, shot dead. Very convenient. Ruth Reddington promptly blindsides Elizabeth by telling the police she the only one who could have done it. 

Review: I enjoy Mignon Eberhart for her descriptions of lush, warm scenes; and she never fails to set them up in my mind's eye. 

A common theme in many of her stories, the innocent protagonist (Elizabeth) is trapped in a worthless marriage, has her next husband all lined already, then winds up being the prime suspect in the murder of husband #1.

The gimmick of the three monkeys is ignored for most of the book, but explained in the end in a rather disappointing connection, with little significance.

The long and complicated explanation at the end was a bit tedious but a satisfactory conclusion.

Understanding the murder requires a visualization of the odd room arrangement, which is described but not illustrated; so here is my version for your enjoyment. Note that Elizabeth has to pass through the "little passage" and Robert's study (murder scene) in order to get to the rest of the house.

Friday, February 8, 2019

The Window at the White Cat by Mary Roberts Rinehart (1910)

About the author: Mary Roberts Rinehart (1876 – 1958) was an American writer, often called the American Agatha Christie, although her first mystery novel was published 14 years before Christie's first novel in 1920. Rinehart is considered the source of the phrase "The butler did it" from her novel The Door (1930), although the novel does not use the exact phrase. Rinehart is also considered to have invented the "Had-I-But-Known" school of mystery writing, with the publication of The Circular Staircase (1908). (from a Wikipedia article).

Major characters:

At the Knox's:
  • Jack Knox, a lawyer, our narrator
  • Fred Knox, his brother
  • Edith Knox, Fred's wife
  • Ellen Butler, widow of Henry Butler
  • Hawes, a butler
At the Fleming's:
  • Allan Fleming, the missing man, the state treasurer
  • Margery Fleming, his daughter
  • Carter, the butler
  • Anna, a maid
  • Delia, a maid
At Bellwood:
  • Miss Letitia Maitland, Margery Fleming's maiden aunt
  • Miss Susan Jane Maitland (called Jane), Margery Fleming's maiden aunt
  • Harry Waldrop, engaged to Margery Fleming, secretary to Allan Fleming
  • Bella MacKenzie, maid
Al Hunter, a detective
Burton, a newspaper man
Henry Butler, a suicide at the White Cat a long time ago
Henry Schwartz, a party boss
Lightfoot, Allan Fleming's cashier
Robert Clarkson, a suicide
Mrs. Allen Fleming - surprise, a second wife

Locale: fictitious locale near Plattsburg (Missouri?)

Synopsis: Margery Fleming comes to attorney Jack Knox seeking help - her father, Allan Fleming, has disappeared. Knox reluctantly agrees, and calls in detective Al Hunter to investigate. Knox is not too concerned about Fleming, as he has been seen around town.

Margery's aunt, Miss Susan Jane Maitland, asks Knox to help her revise her will. Knox goes to her home at Bellwood, and discovers that Jane has disappeared without a trace. At the same time, ten of her 98 precious pearls have disappeared also, apparently a theft.

The two missing persons have left behind notes stating "1122".

Hunter locates Fleming, staying at a local political-drinking-smoking-gambling hideaway called The White Cat. He brings Knox over, they find Fleming has been shot dead just prior to their arrival. Again, an "1122" note is found.

Review:  Mary Roberts Rinehart can write a dark mystery with humor, a rare combination. As the disappearance and mysterious notes mount up, the character list gets longer and longer as new people, mostly relatives, slide into the story. It is obvious there is skullduggery originating with some banking scams, and centered around the sketchy White Cat, which ostensibly is a "political club" but seems more like a frat house. Jane disappears early on, but seems to be forgotten throughout most of the book.

It is satisfying to read a book over 100 years old which still remains a puzzler and a page-turner.

Monday, February 4, 2019

Kept Women Can't Quit by A. A. Fair (1960)


About the author: A. A. Fair is a pseudonym of Erle Stanley Gardner.

Major characters:

Hazel Downer, a.k.a. Hazel Clune - the femme fatale, Standley's "kept woman"
Standley Downer - her common-law husband
Evelyn Ellis, photo model; a.k.a. Beverly Kettle when in San Francisco
Dover C. Inman, owner of the Full Dinner Pail drive in; not to be confused with...
Carl Dover Christopher, president of Christopher, Crowder, and Doyle in Chicago
Jasper Diggs Calhoun, public relations man
Herbert Baxley, the red-headed two-time loser
Bernice Glenn, hotel telephone operator
Ernestine Hamilton, roommate of Bernice Glenn, a wannabee private eye
George Biggs Gridley, non-person, false name created by Donald Lam

Donald Lam, narrator/investigator
Bertha Cool, investigator
Elsie Brand, secretary
Sergeant Frank Sellers

Locale: Los Angeles / San Francisco

Synopsis: Sergeant Frank Sellers is telling investigator/narrator Donald Lam about an unsolved case: An armored car was relieved of $100,000 in $1000 bills while the guards are on coffee break at a drive-in joint. The police have recovered half the cash, but $50,000 is still missing. Herbert Baxley was seen lurking in the vicinity at the time of the theft, and the police suspect him and Hazel Downer (the "kept woman").

Hazel Downer subsequently shows up at the offices of Cool & Lam, asking for help in locating her "husband" (the legality of the marriage seems a bit sketchy), Standley Downer. She claims he has left with $60k of her money, of course in $1000 bills.

Lam goes to San Francisco in search of Downer. He locates an apartment just vacated by Evelyn Ellis, who is Downer's new squeeze. He installs his secretary Elsie Brand in the apartment to observe. He finds Ellis left a locked trunk in the garage. Lam purchases a similar trunk, performs a switch, and winds up with her trunk. He finds $52k in her trunk, which he sends back to his office. Standley is then found - dead - with Lam's trunk all taken apart.

Lam strikes up a friendship with Ernestine Hamilton, roommate of Bernice Glenn, telephone operator at the hotel where everything is happening. Ernestine is a wannabee private eye, so he puts her to work to pump Bernice for hotel dirt.

Review: As in all Cool/Lam stories, this one starts out at full speed and does not let up for a second; which I why I find them easiest to consume in one, maybe two at most, sittings.

By the time of the trunk swap episode, we are already losing track of the various stashes of $1000 bills floating around. Little attention is paid to the murder - everyone is after the money instead.

The episode of Lam enlisting Ernestine Hamilton as an amateur P.I. is different, and enjoyable to see him establish a platonic friendship with a woman.

Gardner's heritage as a pay-by-the-word pulp writer always shows through, with lots of incidental characters and conversations, and of course, characters getting unnecessary middle names, and businesses getting long complex partnership names; in order to get the word count up easily.

One caution: terms used for persons of Japanese ancestry reflect the bias of the times.

Monday, January 28, 2019

The Origin of Evil by Ellery Queen (1951)

Major characters:
  • Leander Hill, jeweler, deceased
  • Laurel Hill, his daughter
  • Roger Priam, jeweler, paraplegic
  • Delia Priam, his femme fatale wife
  • Crowe "Mac" Macgowen, Delia's son, who lives in a treehouse
  • Alfred Wallace, assistant to Roger Priam, and Delia's lover
  • -- Collier, Delia's father
  • Lt. Keats of the police

Locale: Los Angeles, CA

Synopsis: Ellery Queen travels to Los Angeles to relax and write a book. Laurel Hill locates him and asks him to investigate the untimely death of her father, Leander Hill. Leander and Roger Priam are partners in a jewelry business. Hill had found a dead dog and a warning note on his doorstep, and the fright causes a heart attack and his death. Priam, a paraplegic with a femme fatale wife Delia, lives nearby and has a secretary/assistant Alfred Wallace who helps care for him. Priam receives a sealed box which also frightens him. 

Someone is on a revenge trip against them, and with the death of Leander, the threats now focus on Roger Priam. Additional warnings follow.

Ellery finds a blank - nothing can be found about Leander's or Roger's past, or even Alfred's. 

Delia makes come-ons to Ellery. The story comes out that Roger hired Alfred to not only assist him, also to service Delia in his 'absence'.

Leander's daughter Laurel takes the initiative to chase down clues, and enlists Delia's son Crowe Macgowen as well, even sleeping with him to obtain a key to Delia's.

Review: This was written in 1951, at the height of the mid-century modern movement, and this book reflects it. Chapter 1 starts out with a lot of abstraction, and run-on sentences that fill nearly a page each. The first sentence refers to Ellery Queen having a corpse at his feet, and it took a while to realize that the corpse is not a literal corpse, but a metaphor for the city of Los Angeles. I know, quite a stretch. I almost gave up before getting to Chapter 2. Things starting settling down at the end of Chapter 1, and we finally had some Facts: a death under suspicious circumstances.

There is a sexual undercurrent throughout the story, which is unnecessary to the plot and distracting. Delia makes overtures to any male she encounters, and Laurel does not hesitate to use sex to get what she wants from Macgowen. And why does Ellery question witnesses about their sex lives? None of this is relevant, or part of the plot. 

The reveal at the end is incredibly obscure and complex, but does the job but leaves me scratching my head at believability.

Thursday, January 24, 2019

Where There's A Will by Rex Stout (1940)


About the author: Rex Stout (1886 – 1975) was an American writer noted for his detective fiction. His best-known characters are the detective Nero Wolfe and his assistant Archie Goodwin, who were featured in 33 novels and 39 novellas between 1934 and 1975. (wikipedia). (bibliography)

Major characters:

The four Hawthorne siblings:
  • Noel Hawthorne, an attorney, at Daniel Cullen & Co., deceased
  • April Hawthorne, actress
  • May Hawthorne, president of Varney College
  • June [Hawthorne] Dunn
Daisy Hawthorn,  the veiled woman, widow of Noel,

John Charles Dunn, June's husband, US Secretary of State
Andrew, 24, their son
Sara, 22, their daughter

Naomi Karn, Noel's other woman
Celia Fleet, April's secretary
Glenn Prescott, Noel's lawyer

Locale: New York City

Synopsis: Wealthy attorney Noel Hawthorne has been found dead in a field, apparently from a hunting accident. His widow Daisy and three sisters April, May, and June approach Nero Wolfe to resolve an issue about his will. He had left his three sisters each a piece of fruit, some money to his widow Daisy, but the bulk of his estate to a Miss Naomi Karn. Daisy is enigmatic, as she wears a veil all the time to cover a disfigured face.

The sisters are OK with the fruit, since they are all wealthy in their own right. The issue is that Noel had verbally promised $1M to go to the Science Fund at Varney College, run by sister May. They hire Wolfe to contact Naomi Karn and try to get her to fulfill that promise by donating $1M from her portion. 

It seems an easy case. Karn is agreeable to the idea. Before it can proceed, police determine Noel's death was murder. Soon after, Karn meets the same fate.


This early Nero Wolfe is enjoyable, with, of course, a quirky family to deal with and hijinks with a will. The operatives working for him are more ready to get into fights than in later books.

A vital clue is found when a camera is stolen. Wolfe doesn't find the camera, but discovers the exposed film is no longer in the camera, but is out being processed (remember that routine?). He recovers the photos and one of them solves the case. My copy has a page of the 6 photographs in question bound between 220/221, one of which is a photo of Nero and Archie themselves! A primary source of what they really look like! Readers won't see the clue for what it is, only a Nero Wolfe would see the significance; but the 40's era photos are fun to peruse with a magnifying glass.

My copy has a bookworm hole where the worm drilled a tunnel into the pages. This is a common happening in books from the wartime 1940's when a high starch content paper was used, tasty for bookworms!

Saturday, January 19, 2019

Deep Lay the Dead by Frederick C. Davis (1942)


About the author: Frederick Clyde Davis (1902-1977) was an American pulp writer. He was educated at Dartmouth College, Hanover, New Hampshire, and became a professional writer at the age of 22. Davis wrote several novels featuring his series detective, Professor Cy Hatch. He also wrote as Murdo CoombsStephen Ransome and Curtis Steele. (gadetection) ( more )

Major characters:
  • Rigby Webb, professor of mathematics
  • Dr. Duncan Chandler, our host
  • Claire Chandler, his wife
  • Jill Chandler, their daughter
  • Tom Stowell, lawyer
  • Nick Winston, having an affair with Claire Chandler?
  • Tony Raye - gambler and dancer
  • Erica Kerrington, Tony's girlfriend
  • Max Harwick, pianist until his unfortunate accident
  • Ross Harwick, his son, a lawyer
  • Arnold Barclay, host of The Midnight Tattler radio show
  • Mary Peacock, the nurse who disappeared
Locale: rural Pennsylvania

Synopsis: World War II is in progress, and mathematics professor Rigby Webb receives a mysterious call to take a job with a physician, Duncan Chandler, in rural Pennsylvania. He heads there as a major snowstorm sets in. 

Chandler, also an expert on codes and ciphers, has turned his home medical office into a secure room to work on a secret government project - creating an unbreakable cipher for war communications. Webb is also an expert on codes and ciphers, having written academic papers on them. Webb accepts the job offer as his assistant. His previous assistant met with an "accident" which no one talks about. 

One of the guests is bitter Max Harwick, a famous pianist, who has just lost two fingers after a hunting accident. Chandler had to amputate them to save his life, but Harwick's career is ruined. Attorney Ross Harwick, his son, wants an out-of-court settlement, but Chandler insists on going to trial to prove his good intentions.

Word comes that an enemy spy is after the secret cipher. A courier is coming to the house with news of his identity. As he approaches, a shot is fired from an upstairs window, killing the courier and causing him to fall into an abandoned quarry.

With the house firmly snowed in, one of the occupants is likely the enemy spy - and a murderer.


This is an enjoyable book, and it is my tradition to take it off the shelf and read it once a year whenever we get a big snowstorm. It never gets old. Suspicion falls on each person in turn. Rigby Webb is an enjoyable character. There is additional drama with a couple of marital affairs, and Rigby always has his own eye on Jill.

This book really, really needs a sketch map of the home. Perhaps the original edition had one, but my Collier edition does not; so I made my own. This fits the text as best I could make it.

Try to get a copy for your next blizzard. The Collier uniform edition in blue/black binding is much more common than the original printing.